Skip to content
Español

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.


Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

What our customers say about us...

Profile photo of Chrisha Jones

Chrisha Jones

July 2, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Chrisha Jones
"They are always nice."
We responded:
"Thank you Chrisha! We're so glad you choose us for your auto and home insurance needs!

#mattfromstatefarm #omalleyinsurance #autoinsurance #homeinsurance #likeagoodneighbor"
Profile photo of Ashlie King

Ashlie King

July 1, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Ashlie King
"I had a great experience working with Matt O'Malley. Matt was friendly, understanding, and took the time to listen to my needs without making me feel pressured. He explained all of my options clearly and helped me find the best policy that fit both my budget and my coverage needs. His professionalism, knowledge, and excellent customer service made the entire process easy and stress free. I highly recommend Matt O'Malley to anyone looking for an insurance agent who truly cares about helping people find the right coverage."
We responded:
"Ashlie, I can't thank you enough for such a kind review! We'll always be here for you and your family!

#mattfromstatefarm #likeagoodneighbor #autoinsurance #homeinsurance"
Profile photo of Kathy

Kathy

July 1, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Kathy
"Matt and his staff are so helpful and explain everything well. Rates are very competitive. Would do business here any time!!!"
We responded:
"Thank you Kathy! We're so grateful for you!

#mattfromstatefarm #likeagoodneighbor #autoinsurance #homeinsurance"
Profile photo of Colton Heiniger

Colton Heiniger

July 1, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Colton Heiniger
"I'm an accountant and have worked with countless insurance agents. Matt is BY FAR the kindest, down-to-earth, and proactive insurance agent I have ever met. State Farm is very competitive on rates, and we now use him for our car insurance, auto insurance, and professional liability. Could not recommend a better agent. Thanks Matt!"
We responded:
"Colton, thank you so much for your review! It's truly a pleasure being your State Farm Agent! We'll always be here for you and your family!

#likeagoodneighbor #autoinsurance #homeinsurance #professionalliabilityinsurance #mattfromstatefarm"
Profile photo of Nick Long

Nick Long

July 1, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Nick Long
"Best insurance man since insurance was invented. Family values, very professional and made me feel like a brother."
We responded:
"Nick, thank you for such high praise! I'm so grateful for you!

#mattfromstatefarm #heretohelp #autoinsurance #homeinsurance #lifeinsurance #goodneighbor"
Profile photo of Jesse Shawver

Jesse Shawver

July 1, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Jesse Shawver
"Matt was incredibly helpful and went above and beyond to help put myself and my family in the best possible spot for all of our insurance needs. Highly recommend."
We responded:
"Jesse, thank you so much for your kind words and review! We're so grateful for you!

#mattfromstatefarm #autoinsurance #homeinsurance #likeagoodneighbor #indiana"
Profile photo of Jackson Payne

Jackson Payne

June 12, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Jackson Payne
"Matt and his staff are always quick to help with great attitudes. Very much appreciate the entire office!"
We responded:
"Jackson, thank you for the awesome review! Your business means the world to us, and having you as part of the O'Malley State Farm family is a real joy!"
Profile photo of Robbin Greer

Robbin Greer

June 5, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Robbin Greer
"Cyla was the best! She explained things to me that I had no knowledge of, which made perfect sense to me. She took the time to get me the best rate that suits my needs. In thee end my business wasn't just a price tag, I got my money's worth."
We responded:
"Robbin, thank you for your business and such a wonderfully kind review! Your insurance needs are about so much more than price, and we're so happy to hear that you have a clearer understanding of your Auto Insurance!

#MattfromStateFarm #AutoInsurance #HomeInsurance #LifeInsurance #likeagoodneighbor"
Profile photo of Mike Kuhn

Mike Kuhn

June 4, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Mike Kuhn
"Any questions I have sent either by email or text or phone have been replied to within one work day. I'm not saying all the answers are good news but it least it's a start. If only my doctors offices, or elected representatives could do that."
We responded:
"Mike, thank you for reaching out, we are proud to have earned your 5-Star Review! We will always reply to you within a timely manner and, whether we're discussing good or bad news, we'll continue to do so professionally and compassionately.

We're grateful for your business!

#MattfromStateFarm #AutoInsurance #HomeInsurance #LifeInsurance #likeagoodneighbor"
Profile photo of Jasmine Grooms

Jasmine Grooms

May 12, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Jasmine Grooms
"I just switched from Geico to State Farm and ended up saving over 100$ while also getting full coverage on my car, didn’t expect for it so be so easy and that much cheaper! Definitely happy I made the switch."
We responded:
"We're so glad to hear that you're saving money and getting better coverage on your Auto Insurance with State Farm! -Matt

#autoinsurance #likeagoodneighbor "
Profile photo of RJ Fellers

RJ Fellers

April 16, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by RJ Fellers
"I needed to make an adjustment to my auto policy and Cyla was great in getting it updated quickly. She had everything finalized and over to me in about 10 minutes. The O'Malley agency offers great rates & even better service!"
We responded:
"Richard, thank you so much for your amazing review! Our team strives to go above and beyond to provide exceptional customer service! We appreciate you and we're here to help!

#MattfromStateFarm #autoinsurance #homeinsurance #servicematters"
Profile photo of Jacob Lembke

Jacob Lembke

March 27, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Jacob Lembke
"They are always a huge help when I need them and they answer any question. I have no matter how dumb I think it is. They always give me full attention when I call or when I’m there. And they’re always pleasant and always answer when I call! Would highly recommend to anybody!!"
We responded:
"Thank you for your awesome review, Jacob! We're happy you chose us for your Auto, Boat, and Renters Insurance needs! We'll be here if you need us. -#MattfromStateFarm

#ServiceMatters #LikeAGoodNeighbor #AutoInsurance #HomeInsurance #BoatInsurance #LifeInsurance"
Profile photo of Jeff Christopherson

Jeff Christopherson

March 26, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Jeff Christopherson
"I've been with State Farm for over 12 years. Had some recent news that I had to make some changes to my policy. Matt Taylor went above and beyond with helping me retain my account and made sure I was completely satisfied. He kept in contact with me the entire time and took the time to make sure I was getting the best coverage and rate possible. I am not someone that jumps around from company to company loyalty means something. Matt O' Malley really cares about his clients and I wouldn't ever think about switching to anyone else."
We responded:
"Jeff, thank you for sharing your experience with our Agency! Life happens, and we're here to try to help where we can! Thank you for your loyalty!

#ServiceMatters #LikeAGoodNeighbor #MattfromStateFarm #AutoInsurance #HomeInsurance #BoatInsurance #LifeInsurance"
Profile photo of Zoe Greer

Zoe Greer

March 25, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Zoe Greer
"There grate at home insurance and car insurance and all of the insurance you could get"
We responded:
"Thank you for sharing your wonderful experience with our Agency! Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we're always here to make the insurance process smooth and stress-free! -#MattfromStateFarm

#GoodNeighbor #StateFarm #AutoInsurance #HomeInsurance #LifeInsurance"
Profile photo of Luz Rendon

Luz Rendon

March 18, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Luz Rendon
"Great service, best price I could ever find out of all insurance, very nice and quick response, very much appreciated."
We responded:
"Luz, thank you for choosing us to be your Insurance Agency! We're here to help when you need! -Matt O."
Profile photo of Tarndeep Singh

Tarndeep Singh

March 13, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Tarndeep Singh
"I been with matt many years great customer service and very friendly…highly recommended"
We responded:
"Thank you for sharing your wonderful experience with our Agency! Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we're always here to make the insurance process smooth and stress-free!

#GoodNeighbor #StateFarm #AutoInsurance #HomeInsurance #MattfromStateFarm "
Profile photo of Brian Kempiak

Brian Kempiak

March 4, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Brian Kempiak
"The customer service was great."
We responded:
"Brian, thank you for your kind review! We're grateful to have earned your business! "
Profile photo of Shannon Rivers

Shannon Rivers

February 25, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Shannon Rivers
"It is wonderful to experience, in a world where everything is going up, my State Farm insurance rates have went down. I have been a member of the State Farm family for many years. Thank you Matt O'Malley for your continued service and excellent coverage."
We responded:
"Thank you for your amazing review Shannon! Congratulations on your Auto Insurance rate decrease! More good news to come!"
Profile photo of Chris Dongoski

Chris Dongoski

February 25, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Chris Dongoski
"Matt and his crew are top notch! Always very attentive to any issues. I have my home and cars with them and have been extremely pleased. In addition, his team is always suggesting ways to save me money on my insurance needs. Highly recommend!"
We responded:
"Wow Chris, thank you! We appreciate your business and are here to help!"
Profile photo of Beth McAllister

Beth McAllister

February 6, 2026

4  out of  5
rating by Beth McAllister
"Just re-established my car insurance with State Farm. Glad to be back with them and paying half as much! Matt has always been very helpful and personable. Talked with Cyla this time and she seems equally as pleasant as Matt has always been. 😊"
We responded:
"Thank you for your kind words and nice review, Beth! We're so happy to have earned your Auto Insurance business back!"
Profile photo of Tim Cook

Tim Cook

January 16, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Tim Cook
"Matt Taylor WAS FANTASTIC"
We responded:
"Tim, thank you for your nice review! We're happy to be of service to you and your family for your Auto, Home, and Life Insurance needs!"
Profile photo of Lincoln

Lincoln

December 2, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Lincoln
"Best price I could find out of all insurance companies! Also Cyla was amazing when assisting me over the phone, extremely kind, super fast and all around great service!"
We responded:
"Lincoln, thank you for your kind words! We're so glad to have earned your business! "
Profile photo of Rissa _C

Rissa _C

October 2, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Rissa _C
"Great customer service! Listened to all my needs and made the process of getting the proper coverage I needed very simple and easy to understand."
We responded:
"Thank you for your kind words and review! We appreciate you! -Matt O."
Profile photo of Krista Joseph

Krista Joseph

October 2, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Krista Joseph
"Best insurance agency in Fishers and very personable! Thanks Matt Omalley!"
We responded:
"Thank you for your kind words and review! -Matt O."
Profile photo of Tameka Williams

Tameka Williams

September 11, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Tameka Williams
""Matt was wonderful to work with, he answered all of our questions, gave us great information and recommendations, and never made us feel pressured.""
We responded:
"I'm so glad we are able to help provide you and your family with peace-of-mind! We're always here to help and thank you for choosing us for your Auto, Home, and Life Insurance needs. "